❌ Waterproof Shoes - Never dry!
While waterproof shoes can be great for hiking, I don’t recommend them for bikepacking. In my experience, they always end up wet. It’s not surprising when there’s a big hole on top for your foot to go in. And once they’re wet, they never dry. In the southernmost part of our Patagonia trip, my shoes were literally frozen most mornings. Cold, stiff, and miserable to put on. I’d get the coldest feet while walking around camp and packing up, and it wasn’t until 30 minutes into riding that I could feel my toes again. DO NOT RECOMMEND.
Going forward, I’m sticking with lightweight, breathable shoes that dry quickly. If they get soaked, I can always swap into sandals or pull on some waterproof socks.
✅ Waterproof Pants or Shorts - 60/40
Just like with shoes, I found waterproof pants less suited to bikepacking than to hiking. No matter what, I always ended up soaked, either from sweat building up inside or rain getting in from the outside. The only upside is that if it’s cold, at least you’re wet and warm, thanks to the steamy environment they create.
Our pants also weren’t the best quality, I’m sure better ones exist. Sophia actually liked hers a lot, and I’ll admit there were a few days I was really glad to have them.
In the end, I think it really depends on the climate. If it’s warm and rainy, I wouldn’t bother. I’d just ride in shorts that dry fast. But if it’s likely to get cold, I’d definitely bring a pair, being cold and wet on the bike is miserable.